Skip to main content

Taking the editorial decision

Accessing the decisions

 

Once expected reports are received, the article will switch to 'Waiting editorial decision'.

This unlocks new actions related to editorial decision:

image.png


If these buttons are not displayed, this means that there is still at least one referee invited. Please click on the ‘Cancel pending referees’ button to un-invite or un-assign these referees.


image.png

 


Proposals and decisions

 

Depending on your profile rights, you may propose or take a decision.

  • Proposing a decision will return the article to your parent editor (who becomes current editor of the article)
  • Taking a decision will send the editorial decision directly to the author

 

The recommandation system

There are three decision groups:

  • Acceptance / Propose acceptance
  • Revision / Propose revision
  • Rejection / Propose rejection

Depending on the journal and your profile, each group will offer different choices. Typically for revisions, you will have the choice between requesting a minor or a major revision.

image.png

 

Clicking on the recommandation will pop-up the decision module:

 

image.png

 

For each decision

 

 

 

Reject / Request Revision / Accept = in this case, you will send the decision letter directly to the author.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Submit an editor report

 

 

 

 

 

Back to top